NorthWind Analytics · The Bosun's Locker
Why the 12% bracket can cost you 22% — and where it stops
Social Security is not taxed like other income. As your other income rises, a larger share of your benefit becomes taxable — up to 85% of it. So one extra dollar of IRA withdrawal can add well over a dollar to your taxable income, and the rate you actually pay on it bears no relation to the bracket you think you are in.
The part nobody tells you. It ends. Once 85% of the benefit is taxable, there is nothing left to drag in and the rate drops back to the ordinary bracket. The expensive stretch is a band, not a slope — and knowing where it starts and stops is what makes it manageable.
Annual figures, before any additional withdrawal.
Rate on your next dollar withdrawn
—
Your position on the curve, and what it costs.
Measured by adding a slice of income and reading the change in tax — not read off a bracket table. The shaded row is the most expensive place to stand.
The arithmetic, in plain terms.
Provisional income is all your other income, plus any tax-exempt interest, plus half of your Social Security benefit. Below the first base — $25,000 single, $32,000 joint — none of the benefit is taxed. Between the two bases, 50 cents of benefit becomes taxable for each additional dollar. Above the second base — $34,000 and $44,000 — it is 85 cents per dollar, until 85% of the whole benefit is taxable and the process stops.
That is where the spike comes from. In the 85-cent stretch, one extra dollar of withdrawal adds $1.85 to taxable income. Taxed at 12%, that is 22.2 cents of tax on a single dollar. The bracket table still says 12%. Both are true; only one is the rate you actually pay.
A second, separate surcharge. For tax years 2025 through 2028 only, filers aged 65 and over get a bonus deduction of $6,000 each, clawed back at 6 cents per dollar of income above $150,000 joint or $75,000 single. While it is being clawed back, each extra dollar of income raises taxable income by $1.06, which adds about 6% of your bracket rate on top. This tool shades it separately from the torpedo, because the two are frequently confused and only one of them expires. They can overlap, and where they do, the surcharges add.
Not modelled. State income tax, the Medicare surcharge, the net investment income tax on top of the band, credits, and the separate rules for married filing separately. Figures are the published 2026 and 2027 amounts from IRS Revenue Procedures 2025-32 and 2026-35. This is an educational projection, not advice or a prepared return.